Which historical culture for multicultural classrooms? Self-reflections of teachers when recalling their lessons on sensitive issues.
This? ?paper? ?is? ?based? ?on? ?the? ?hypothesis? ?that? ?the? ?current? ?context? ?of? ?multicultural? ?classrooms, instead? ?than? ?simply? ?presenting? ?students? ?with? ?national? ?master? ?narratives,? ?requires? ?to? ?enhance? ?the didactical? ?goal? ?of? ?training? ?reflective? ?and? ?critical? ?citizens? ?of? ?new? ?multicultural? ?societies? ?(Seixas, 2017).? ?However,? ?despite? ?a? ?growing? ?critical? ?awareness? ?of? ?the? ?need? ?for? ?a? ?multicultural? ?approach? ?to historical? ?culture? ?(see? ?Carretero,? ?Berger? ?and? ?Grever? ?2017),? ?empirical? ?researches? ?conducted? ?in countries? ?all? ?over? ?the? ?world? ?still? ?show? ?a? ?strong? ?opposition? ?to? ?the? ?idea? ?of? ?eroding? ?national frameworks? ?of? ?historical? ?accounts,? ?opposition? ?shared? ?not? ?only? ?by? ?the? ?public? ?at? ?large? ?but? ?also? ?by policymakers? ?(Carretero? ?2011).
48
Therefore,? ?in? ?spite? ?(or? ?perhaps? ?because?)? ?of? ?the? ?new? ?historical? ?condition? ?of? ?globalization? ?we? ?are living? ?in,? ?empirical? ?data? ?are? ?showing? ?that? ?history? ?teaching? ?is? ?still? ?very? ?focused? ?on? ?the? ?building? ?of an? ?"imagi-nation"? ?(Carretero,? ?2017),? ?struggling? ?against? ?evidence? ?to? ?overlap? ?the? ?contemporary “we”? ?with? ?the? ?historical? ?“we”.
Taken? ?into? ?account? ?this? ?tension? ?between? ?contemporary? ?insurgence? ?of? ?the? ?need? ?for? ?a multicultural? ?historical? ?culture? ?and? ?the? ?permanence? ?of? ?national? ?frameworks? ?of? ?historical accounts,? ?a? ?research? ?question? ?emerges.? ?When? ?facing? ?the? ?history? ?curriculum? ?they? ?are? ?presented with,? ?as? ?a? ?guideline? ?due? ?to? ?the? ?policy? ?of? ?their? ?governments? ?–? ?governments? ?that? ?in? ?Western societies? ?are? ?expected? ?to? ?keep? ?changing? ?in? ?time? ?according? ?to? ?democratic? ?rules? ?–,? ?to? ?what? ?extent and? ?how? ?may? ?history? ?teachers? ?“make? ?use? ?of? ?this? ?guidelines? ?with? ?content-driven? ?creativity” (B